Assembly vs BASIC

10 Print is a "native" BASIC program, which is just to say that it was originally written in BASIC for the C64, and not first rendered in assembly and later reimplemented. For that reason, no canonical assembly program exists. As with literary translation or artistic adaptation, there are multiple ways to recast a computer program from one language into another, even on a relatively simple system like the C64, and even with a relatively simple program like 10 Print. The following rendition was authored by Ian Bogost, Stephane Hockenhull, and Nick Montfort, in the context of the demo scene event @party in July 2010.

10 Print is a "native" BASIC program, which is just to say that it was originally written in BASIC for the C64, and not first rendered in assembly and later reimplemented. For that reason, no canonical assembly program exists. As with literary translation or artistic adaptation, there are multiple ways to recast a computer program from one language into another, even on a relatively simple system like the C64, and even with a relatively simple program like 10 Print. The following rendition was authored by Ian Bogost, Stephane Hockenhull, and Nick Montfort, in the context of the demo scene event @party in July 2010.

lda #$80 ; set this value in...

lda #$80 ; set this value in...

jsr $ffd2 ; output character via kernal routine

jsr $ffd2 ; output character via kernal routine

bne loop ; repeat

bne loop ; repeat

[Note: a complete, line-by-line explication of this program is needed, but I've omitted it for the time being, since such an act is really just an exercise and won't require much thinking to do, just time.]

[Note: a complete, line-by-line explication of this program is needed, but I've omitted it for the time being, since such an act is really just an exercise and won't require much thinking to do, just time.]

BASIC makes both of these acts compact and accessible. Print a character, generate a random number. Normally, carrying out either of these in assembly is an arduous task. Here's an example of a commonly used routine for generating a random 8-bit number in 6502 assembly:

BASIC makes both of these acts compact and accessible. Print a character, generate a random number. Normally, carrying out either of these in assembly is an arduous task. Here's an example of a commonly used routine for generating a random 8-bit number in 6502 assembly:

lda random ; get seed from memory (must be non-zero)

lda random ; get seed from memory (must be non-zero)

asl ; shift byte

asl ; shift byte

Rand8.no_eor

Rand8.no_eor

sta random ; save number as next seed

sta random ; save number as next seed

This routine is nine bytes long, or 25% of the space needed for the entire 10 Print program in BASIC. That's not surprising; a high-level language is supposed to abstract more complex, lower-level routines into more easily usable functions. But such functions can also be built into the hardware itself, stored in ROM as executable instructions, or produced through a combination of seemingly unrelated affordances.

This routine is nine bytes long, or 25% of the space needed for the entire 10 Print program in BASIC. That's not surprising; a high-level language is supposed to abstract more complex, lower-level routines into more easily usable functions. But such functions can also be built into the hardware itself, stored in ROM as executable instructions, or produced through a combination of seemingly unrelated affordances.

But an even stranger approach to random number generation on the machine involves the C64 sound chip, another MOS Technologies integrated circuit, part 6581, also known as the Sound Interface Device or SID. The SID is a programmable sound generator chip which was responsible for the C64's distinctive audio abilities. Apart from its sonic functions, the SID also has he ability to generate random values. To do so, the programmer must select the noise waveform on the SID's voice 3 oscillator and set that voice's frequency to a non-zero value. Setting a higher frequency value will cause the noise values to change more rapidly, yielding a greater variety of random numbers. The first three instructions of the assembly program above accomplish these settings:

But an even stranger approach to random number generation on the machine involves the C64 sound chip, another MOS Technologies integrated circuit, part 6581, also known as the Sound Interface Device or SID. The SID is a programmable sound generator chip which was responsible for the C64's distinctive audio abilities. Apart from its sonic functions, the SID also has he ability to generate random values. To do so, the programmer must select the noise waveform on the SID's voice 3 oscillator and set that voice's frequency to a non-zero value. Setting a higher frequency value will cause the noise values to change more rapidly, yielding a greater variety of random numbers. The first three instructions of the assembly program above accomplish these settings:

sta $d40f ; ... the noise speed hi SID register

sta $d40f ; ... the noise speed hi SID register

sta $d412 ; ... and the noise waveform SID register

sta $d412 ; ... and the noise waveform SID register

... and once done, the program can get a new 8-bit random number by reading from memory location $d41b. While it looks a little messier than just calling RND in BASIC, the result is equally abstracted from the programmer's perspective--it's just abstracted to a different place, namely the SID chip.

... and once done, the program can get a new 8-bit random number by reading from memory location $d41b. While it looks a little messier than just calling RND in BASIC, the result is equally abstracted from the programmer's perspective--it's just abstracted to a different place, namely the SID chip.